Your premier jewelry destination in Tallahassee: Diamonds, Engagement Rings & More

At The Gem Collection we are passionate about two things: beautiful jewelry and our valued customers! We meticulously search the world to bring an exceptional selection of diamonds, engagement rings, wedding rings, estate jewelry, colored gemstones, fashion jewelry, and designer pieces, right here in Tallahassee.

Pandora The Gem Collection

Our experienced jewelry experts are always here to help you find the perfect piece, ensuring your satisfaction with every purchase. Whether you're shopping for a once-in-a-lifetime engagement ring or adding to your collection, we want you to be absolutely delighted with your beautiful jewelry!

Bridal & Wedding

Engagement
Wedding
Wedding Party

Shop by category

18.00ct Emerald Cut Smoky Quartz Ring
Estate Jewelry
6-Prong 1.10ct Marquise Diamond Ring
Wedding Jewelry
The Birdy 34mm Watch by Shinola
Shinola Watches
3.07cttw Alexandrite & Diamond Pave Pendant & Chain by Mark Henry
Colored Stone Jewelry
Two-Tone Mounting Set with 2.01ct I VVS1 Emerald Cut Diamond
Diamond Jewelry
Presage Cocktail Time Watch by Seiko
Designer Jewelry
Pearl and Diamond Children's Earrings
Children's Jewelry
2.00tdw Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring
Lab Grown Diamonds

Testimonials

★★★★★

This is one of the best stores in the city. Their customer service and attention to detail is unparalleled. Veronica is by far the most amazing designer of custom jewelry that I have run across. She always has incredible ideas to make pieces work with any existing pieces you may already have. She finds quality gems at reasonable prices. The owners are always providing artistically designed pieces that would be difficult to find anywhere else. A fascinating store with many beautiful items!

Mary R
★★★★★

I moved to TLH 7 years ago from SF via LA via NC. I had several pieces of jewelry that needed cleaning, settings secured and appraised. Loved, loved Alan. I’m certain we laughed too much and too loudly. His mother breeds Shi Tzus. We have (had) much in common. When he was thinking of returning to (Major Retailor), he said to me, ‘I’ve hand picked your Salesperson. The two of you will work great together.’ He was right; we have. Amy is Phenomenal !. She knows what I am thinking before I do. I LOVE her. Although, at My Age, I needed to realign my finances, Gem Collection is The Only jewelry store in which I trade. Christmas is coming. I’ve asked my children for their list. Of course I HAVE mine (. Others first). If I have scraps, I’ll buy for myself at Gem Collection.

Signed,
Loyal Customer, Never Disappointed

Kimberly
★★★★★

Thanks Abby for the fine recommendation with this wedding ring that needed some TLC. The Gem Collection absolutely updated my favorite piece of jewelry. The appraisal was very impressive, attention with details was absolutely amazing. ❤️

Richard M
★★★★★

This jewelry store is beautiful. What makes it even more appealing is the Team there, including Amy and Michelle. You are treated like family. No high pressure sales, just service and a smile. They get you dialed in whether just browsing or need a repair. Inexpensive repairs and most done on the spot. It is a pleasure to visit there, and the owner is a very good person and usually on site.

Jerry P
★★★★★

Sara is absolutely amazing! She is super kind and helps me out so much with choosing pretty things.

Savannah R
★★★★★

I had a wonderful experience at the Gem Collection, Brian helped me through my whole journey of finding the right wedding band for my engagement ring. I feel like an old friend when I walk through the door, and I've never had to wait for professional and friendly service. I look forward to future purchases at this establishment. I would also again like to say Brian went above and beyond to make sure my ring was exactly what I wanted. Thanks

Amber M
★★★★★

Michelle has been our “go to girl“ for years! That would be mom, myself and two sisters. She is awesome!

Gaye
★★★★★

Purchased a wedding band and engagement ring with my wife and the experience in its entirety was absolutely phenomenal! Michelle and Mark provided the best customer service! Would absolutely recommend going to Gem Collection! 10 out of 10!

Scott A
★★★★★

The GEM Collection was amazing and so caring when restoring my mom’s ring and turning it into a piece of jewelry that preserves and honors her memory. The staff is amazing and the quality of work is incrediblez

Monica R
View our latest issue

Trends & Treasures

Click here to see our most up-to-date Jewelry, On Sale Items and Special Editions

Click To Apply

VISIT US IN-STORE

3501 Thomasville Rd, Tallahassee, FL
(850) 893-4171

STORE HOURS
Tuesday - Saturday: 10am - 6pm
Sunday & Monday: Closed